Published 19 November 2026
What is really on the table with the Dutch terrorism proposal 36 984 — and where it goes too far for me
On 17 and 18 November 2026, twenty amendments (proposed changes) were tabled in the Dutch House of Representatives to proposal 36 984, a proposal to change the law on taking away Dutch nationality in cases of terrorism. The committee meeting on it is on Thursday 26 November. I have read the texts. This is not about proposal 34 632, which would end the principle of having only one nationality and could repair the position of former Dutch nationals who mostly lost their nationality without wanting it or knowing it. But one can affect the other. And things are being added that have nothing to do with terrorism. This is how legislation slips in under many people’s radar. Terrorism!? ‘Yes, I am against that too, and it can be dealt with firmly.’ Many people think that, even I do. But here?
First, half a reassurance
No amendment has been tabled that is aimed specifically at former Dutch nationals. But indirectly they are hit after all. So, not intended that way, but once again poorly thought-through legislation that hits not only people who want to become Dutch, but also former Dutch nationals. Nothing about the 13-Year Clock, nothing about getting Dutch nationality back, nothing that specifically touches the position of people who lost their Dutch nationality without wanting to. And nothing about dual nationality as such. But indirectly, yes. Read on.
Given the tone of what is on the table, that is more than a small thing. It could have been worse.
But do not let that reassure you. Anyone who reads these papers sees how fast it can go: a proposal of three articles, on one subject, eight days before the debate suddenly looked like a complete overhaul. With that attitude, we need to watch closely what is actually discussed and decided in the House. An amendment can be tabled right up to the day of the debate.
How this is possible: the trick is in the first two lines
Each of these amendments starts the same way. Not with the content, but with the title of the proposal. The words “the Dutch Nationality Act and” are added to the title. And to the stated reasons: “and that it is also desirable to amend the Dutch Nationality Act”. After that comes a new article IA each time, and that is where the real change sits.
What was this proposal about? Since 01 March 2017, the Dutch Minister of Justice and Security can take away the Dutch nationality of someone who has joined, abroad, an organisation on a list of terrorist organisations. That power ends on 01 March 2027. Proposal 36 984 does one thing: it repeals the 2017 law one day before the power ends, so that the power stays. The government itself writes: “This proposal does not make any changes of substance.” (our translation)
Widen the title, and you widen what else may be brought into this debate. And here it comes.
Naturalisation only after ten years
The members Markuszower and Lammers (Groep Markuszower) propose to replace “five years” with “ten years” in article 8, and to scrap the shorter period of two years. Their explanation: “Five years of residence does not make someone Dutch.” (our translation)
This is not new. The previous Dutch government put the same idea out for public consultation in 2025, and it was never sent to the House. What is new is that it now comes in through an amendment to a proposal on fighting terrorism, without advice from the Council of State on this text and without a check on whether it can be carried out in practice. On top of that, they scrap the rule that two years is enough for someone who has already lived in the Kingdom as a foreigner for ten years or more in total — the person who comes back. Someone who lived in the Netherlands for fifteen years, left for a few years and returns needs two years today and would need ten. These are former immigrants, often children born in the Netherlands, who left and, once back, must still wait an extra ten years before they are welcome. That has nothing to do with civic integration or settling in. It has to do with not wanting certain people as Dutch neighbours.
Either way, this does not only hit people who want to become Dutch. Foreigners who want to become Dutch: look at the trend of the past year. Why are there more naturalisations? In my view, because of these same politicians and their rhetoric. That is at least what I hear from these new Dutch nationals. People are afraid and look for security in nationality. Whoever waits now is gambling with five years of their life, and with uncertainty about what those five years as an immigrant in the new (sarcasm) Netherlands will look like, and the years after.
The naturalisation stop — and why it also hits former Dutch nationals
The same members propose a new article 23a. The minister could then, by government decree, stop the granting of Dutch nationality and the confirmation of option declarations, and suspend the time limits for decisions. For at most twelve months, which can be extended once by twelve months. Their explanation: “This amendment puts on the brakes.” And as a closing line: “The Netherlands decides for itself who becomes Dutch, and when!” (our translation) A pointless sentence, because nobody but the Netherlands decides its own laws or the treaties it signs and keeps. But it is clear what they want, and at whom they are pointing. The members support this with figures, which I give here as their figures, not mine: in 2025, 55,990 people would have become Dutch, twice as many as in 2018, with only 830 refusals against 49,640 approvals. I have not checked these numbers myself with Statistics Netherlands (CBS) or the immigration service (IND).
And now the part nobody seems to have noticed.
The amendment makes two exceptions: becoming Dutch automatically by law, and becoming Dutch to prevent statelessness. Everything in between can be stopped — and the option falls right in the middle.
The option is precisely the route for former Dutch nationals. Someone who settles in the Netherlands again gets Dutch nationality back through an option declaration. And someone who lost it automatically by law, while that had disproportionate consequences for their EU citizenship, has also had an option right since 01 April 2022. The law says so in as many words:
“the foreign national who lost Dutch nationality by operation of law, if with that loss EU citizenship was lost and at that moment it was reasonably foreseeable that this would lead to disproportionate consequences from the point of view of EU law. The recovery takes effect back to and including the moment at which Dutch nationality was lost.” (our translation)
That rule is there for a reason. It came after the Court of Justice of the European Union ruled in the Tjebbes case that losing Dutch nationality is not simply allowed when EU citizenship disappears with it: the proportionality of the consequences must be looked at in each individual case. The Netherlands carried out that ruling by turning it into an option right. An option right that runs through article 6.
And it is exactly article 6 that can be suspended under a naturalisation stop.
So this is what is on the table: the only route the Netherlands has built to meet the European principle of proportionality can be frozen by decree for twelve months, plus another twelve months. For someone who has been waiting years for repair, that is not an administrative measure.
I am not saying the members intended this. Honestly, I think they did not think of it. But that is what the text says, and in legislation what counts is what is written.
And then the obvious question. If the European Union is in the way, are we also going to leave the Charter of Fundamental Rights of the European Union, and so the EU itself? That is exactly what another amendment proposes with the other treaty. More on that below. It sounds like the Brexit rhetoric, where first refugees were blamed, and when their numbers turned out to be so small, the blame moved to Eastern European migrants with free movement. Then came the bent bananas, and now the UK is left with the economic damage and may want to go back.
The rest, in short
No more exemption from the language and integration requirement. The requirement could only be waived in one case: someone who, because of a mental or physical impairment or an intellectual disability, cannot meet it within five years. And explicitly: efforts made “have no significance in applying that requirement” (our translation). So someone who tried for years and did not pass has, according to this text, not tried.
Fraud no longer expires. The twelve-year limit within which Dutch nationality can be taken away for a false statement or deceit would disappear. There is something to be said for that. It also means that a flaw in a file from 1998 could still have consequences today. Still, this worries me somewhat, because I see cases where the government itself caused situations that were later blamed on the person. But fine, this can be acceptable to some extent, as long as a court can look at it when things go wrong.
The third-generation rule disappears. Article 3, paragraph 3, would be scrapped: a child born in the Netherlands to a parent who was also born here would no longer become Dutch automatically by law. There is a transitional rule for those born before the change takes effect. Well, that clearly has nothing to do with civic integration or settling in either: foreigners are apparently always unwelcome, even after three generations. Plain language, as you would expect from certain politicians.
A new ground for taking away nationality for serious crimes. Ordinary crime, then; it has nothing to do with terrorism. Taking away nationality would also become possible after a final conviction for a crime that carries a sentence of five years or more. Well, the Middle Ages and banishment are back. Next year perhaps physical punishment, like chopping off a hand for theft (according to legend, the Dutch-language city of Antwerp got its name from ‘hand werpen’, throwing a hand).
On terrorism, and where I do have some understanding
Let me be clear here, because I do not want to be misunderstood.
I understand the concern. A society must be able to protect itself. Someone who joins an organisation abroad that carries out attacks, and who keeps at it, is a real danger. In such serious cases I understand, to some extent, that a state falls back on something old-fashioned: banishment. Not because it is nice, but because there are situations where nothing else is left.
But there is one condition, and as far as I am concerned it is not negotiable. Banishment can only be justified if it is likely that recovery — rehabilitation, return to society — is unlikely. That is a heavy judgement about one human being, and it must be made case by case, with a court, please.
And: why nationality of all things? This tool only works on people who have a second nationality, because making someone stateless is not allowed. Someone who is only Dutch is outside it, however dangerous he is. So it is not the danger someone poses that decides whether this law can hit him; his nationality decides that. In the United Kingdom and in Australia there is a measure that affects every citizen equally: a temporary ban on entering the country, with a permit to return and a review. An old-fashioned banishment. I am not arguing for that. I am pointing out that of all the tools available, the one chosen is the only one that sorts people by nationality.
And note the difference in price between the two treaties that stand in the way. The European Convention on Nationality can be left at any time; three months after the letter, it is over. The ban on refusing your own citizen entry to the country is in the Fourth Protocol to the European Convention on Human Rights, and that protocol cannot be left on its own: it applies all the rules of the Convention, and the Convention can only be left as a whole. Anyone who wants to get past that brake does not leave a protocol, but the whole European Convention on Human Rights — the protection of everyone in the Netherlands.
And now the question I cannot get answered.
The member Vondeling (PVV) proposes to delete from article 14, paragraph 4, the words “has reached the age of eighteen and”. Only those words. No lower age limit comes in their place. Nothing comes in their place. In her explanation she writes that “no distinction should be made between minors and adults” and that what should decide is “the danger the person in question poses, and not age” (our translation). She speaks of child soldiers.
For a fifteen-year-old I can imagine something. A fifteen-year-old may have been trained, may have made a choice, may be dangerous and unchangeable. But this text does not stop at fifteen. Without a minimum age, it applies just as much to a five-year-old. Explain to me how you establish that recovery is unlikely for a five-year-old. That is not a rhetorical question; it is the question the law should answer before it takes a child’s citizenship away. A five-year-old in a camp has chosen nothing. And taking away nationality means: never being able to come back.
The same member proposes to scrap the compulsory court review. Today: someone who loses Dutch nationality on this ground is by definition abroad and often does not go to court himself, so the minister brings the case to a court within twenty-eight days if the person does not. That way every decision is looked at by a judge, no matter what. The amendment calls this “the world turned upside down, that the Dutch State itself takes action to safeguard the rights of persons who have turned against the Netherlands” (our translation).
Put next to that the figure the government itself gives. The power has been used 25 times. Two decisions were overturned by a court; after that the minister withdrew the decision himself in five similar cases; in two other cases the court overturned it too. Nine of the twenty-five did not stand. That is what the automatic review has done. And that is what would go.
All right. These are exceptional cases, there are few of them, and in the end politics decides how it wants to arrange this. I accept that.
But this is where I do object
One amendment does not only create a new ground for taking away nationality, but also this: “The intention to withdraw from the European Convention on Nationality (Trb. 1998, 10) is approved for the whole Kingdom.” (our translation)
The explanation is open about it: “Because the European Convention on Nationality (ECN) does not allow this ground, the amendment also arranges approval of the intention to withdraw from that convention.” (our translation)
The treaty stands in the way of the measure, so the treaty has to go. That same treaty forbids taking away nationality in a way that makes someone stateless, which protects everyone.
This is no longer only about terrorists. This is about all of us.
Those treaties are not there to protect extremists. They are there to stop a state from taking its own citizens’ citizenship away whenever it suits. They protect the Dutch national in Sydney just as much as the Dutch national in Amsterdam, and the Dutch national with one surname just as much as the one with two.
This is also how it started in Germany in the 1930s. First it was individuals, convicted of serious crimes, whom nobody stood up for. Then the group they were counted among paid the price. The step that made that possible was not the first conviction. It was the moment when the safeguards that applied to everyone were dropped because they were in the way.
I am not saying anyone wants that today. I am saying that this is the order in which it goes, and that we know that order.
That is why: punishment should be individual, judged person by person, and it should stay within the standards we have agreed as a modern society. Especially after all our lessons from history. That is exactly what those international treaties guard — for every Dutch national, whatever their background, origin or second passport.
Leaving a treaty because it is in the way is not a legal operation. It is removing the lock from the door of your own house because you cannot get past it for a moment yourself.
What does this mean for you, as a non-terrorist?
- Nothing has changed yet. These are proposals. An amendment needs a majority, and after that the whole proposal must still pass both the House of Representatives and the Senate.
- For former Dutch nationals, there is something unfavourable on the table right now. The naturalisation stop can also hit the option procedure, and that is your route.
- Do not wait if you already meet the conditions. With ten years and a possible stop on the table, waiting has become more costly.
- Is your option or naturalisation application in progress? Watch the time limits. The legal time limit for a decision on an option is thirteen weeks, which can be extended once by thirteen weeks. Once that has passed, you can formally put the authority in default. But that comes with a warning too: see here why putting them in default can backfire.
- Do you have a child who is Dutch automatically as the third generation? Make sure that is on record: apply for a passport or ID card in good time and keep the proof.
- The debate is on 26 November. Before that day, let your MPs know what this means for you.
One more remark
This law is about a small number of people. There are not that many terrorists on earth or in the Netherlands, or with a Dutch passport. The numbers are tiny, but the impact they have is disastrous. Every innocent victim is one too many. But every innocent victim the other way is also one too many. So let us keep a close eye on this sword. A law on fighting terrorism into which other legislation is slipped — I object to that. Then let it be put forward as a separate proposal, or let the whole law be reviewed and modernised, as I propose in my recently published booklet, Lost by Operation of Law.
What I need to add
Of the twenty amendments, eight are the originals — nos. 9 to 16, all of 17 November — and twelve are replacement versions: no. 17 still on 17 November, nos. 18 to 28 on 18 November. So there are eight subjects, six of which were replaced, some twice and the naturalisation stop three times. I checked the latest versions: the legal text they propose has not changed; the explanation for the naturalisation stop was rewritten, and that is where the figures above come from. One quote is not from the latest version: the passage about leaving the treaty is in no. 13, which was replaced on 18 November by no. 22, and that last document could not yet be viewed on the day of writing. The two amendments by the member Vondeling have not been replaced.
I follow everything about Dutch nationality law and will be in touch when there is more news.
This is general information, not legal advice about your situation. Translated from the Dutch original of 19 November 2026; the quotes from Dutch documents are our translation.
See also the earlier news of the same day: Politics and Nationality, November 2026
This post reflects the position on 19 November 2026. The law and the practice may have moved on since.